Frozen and Burst Pipes: What Home Insurance Pays and What It Doesn’t

Frozen and Burst Pipes: What Home Insurance Pays and What It Doesn't | Longmeadow Insurance

When a pipe freezes and bursts suddenly, homeowners insurance usually pays for the water damage, as long as you kept the heat on or shut off and drained the water. Damage from a slow leak that went on for weeks, from a house left unheated, or from water backing up through a drain is a different story, and is often excluded or needs its own coverage.

A Chicago-area cold snap does not have to last long to split a pipe. Supply lines in exterior walls, crawl spaces, attached garages and above unheated porches are the usual suspects, especially in older North Shore homes where plumbing was added or rerouted over the decades. The water damage from one split copper line can run through two floors before anyone notices, so it pays to know how the policy reads before January.

What a Typical Homeowners Policy Says

Most homeowners policies cover a sudden and accidental discharge of water from plumbing, heating or air conditioning systems. Freezing gets its own condition. The common wording says damage caused by freezing of the plumbing or heating system is not covered unless you used reasonable care to maintain heat in the building, or to shut off the water supply and drain the systems and appliances. That condition is the one that decides most frozen-pipe claims.

SituationUsually covered?Why
A pipe in an exterior wall bursts during a cold snap while the house is heatedYesSudden and accidental discharge, and heat was maintained
The furnace quits while you are away and pipes freezeOften yes, if you can show you kept the heat on and checked the houseReasonable care is a question of fact
The house sits unheated and undrained for weeksOften noFreezing condition not met; vacancy terms may also apply
A slow drip inside a wall rots the subfloor over monthsUsually noContinuous or repeated leakage is excluded
Water comes up through a floor drainOnly with water backup coverageBackup is excluded unless endorsed
The pipe or fixture that failedDepends on the causePolicies often pay to open walls and repair water damage; wear and tear on the pipe itself is excluded

“Reasonable Care” in Practice

Reasonable care is not defined with a number in most policies, which is why the facts matter. An adjuster will want to know what the thermostat was set to, whether the furnace was serviced, whether anyone was checking the house, and how long the heat was off. A household that kept the thermostat at a normal setting and had a furnace fail overnight is in a very different position from a house that sat unheated for a month.

If you leave for more than a few days in winter, the details in our post on leaving your North Shore home for the winter apply: have someone check the house, keep the heat on, and consider shutting off the main water valve. Many policies also limit coverage once a home has been vacant for an extended period, often 60 consecutive days.

Slow Leaks Are the Bigger Trap

A burst pipe announces itself. A pinhole leak behind a wall or under a vanity does not, and by the time the floor is soft or mold appears, the damage has usually been building for weeks. Most policies exclude damage from continuous or repeated seepage or leakage over a period of weeks or months, and mold coverage is often capped at a low limit. That makes small leaks the water loss most likely to come out of your own pocket.

The practical defense is early detection. Water sensors near the water heater, washer, dishwasher and sump pit cost little, and an automatic shutoff valve on the main line can stop a loss in minutes. Some insurers offer a premium credit for them.

Condo Owners and Renters

In a condo building, a burst pipe raises the question of whose policy pays for what. The association’s master policy usually covers the building structure, and your HO-6 covers your belongings, the interior finishes the declaration assigns to you, and your liability if water from your unit damages a neighbor’s. If the association’s deductible is charged back to the owners, the loss assessment coverage on your HO-6 is what answers it. Our posts on the master policy vs. HO-6 and loss assessment coverage walk through both.

Renters are in a simpler spot. The landlord’s policy covers the building. A renters policy covers your belongings and your liability if water from your unit damages the unit below.

What to Do When a Pipe Bursts

  1. Shut off the main water valve. Know where it is before you need it, usually where the water line enters the basement.
  2. Turn off power to wet areas if water is near outlets or the electrical panel, and only if you can do it safely.
  3. Photograph everything before you start cleanup, including the failed pipe.
  4. Start drying. Your policy expects you to protect the property from further damage. Keep receipts for fans, dehumidifiers and emergency mitigation.
  5. Keep the failed section of pipe. It can show whether the cause was freezing, corrosion or a defective fitting.
  6. Report the claim and ask what the insurer needs before repairs start.

Preventing a Freeze

  • Keep the heat on, including when you are away. Many plumbers suggest not setting the thermostat below 55 degrees.
  • Open sink cabinet doors on exterior walls during a deep freeze so warm air reaches the pipes.
  • Let a faucet on an exterior wall drip on the coldest nights.
  • Disconnect garden hoses and shut off and drain outdoor spigots in the fall.
  • Insulate pipes in crawl spaces, attached garages and unheated rooms.
  • Seal drafts around sill plates and where pipes pass through exterior walls.

Check Your Limits Before Winter

Three items on the declarations page decide how a water loss goes: the deductible, whether water backup coverage is included and at what limit, and whether the dwelling limit would rebuild a finished basement at today’s prices. If you have a finished lower level, our guide to sewer backup vs. flood insurance explains why the backup limit is often set too low.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does homeowners insurance cover frozen pipes?

Usually, if you used reasonable care to keep the house heated or shut off and drained the water. Damage from freezing in a house left unheated, or from a slow leak over weeks, is often excluded.

Does insurance pay to replace the burst pipe itself?

It depends on why the pipe failed. Many policies pay to open walls and repair the water damage, while wear, corrosion and deterioration of the pipe itself are excluded. Ask the adjuster how your policy treats the failed section.

What temperature should I keep my house at to prevent frozen pipes?

Many plumbers suggest keeping the thermostat at 55 degrees or higher, including when you are away. Pipes in exterior walls, crawl spaces and garages can still freeze in extreme cold, so open cabinet doors and let a faucet drip on the coldest nights.

Who pays when a burst pipe in my condo damages the unit below?

It depends on the declaration and on fault. The master policy usually covers the building, and your HO-6 liability coverage answers damage you are responsible for in a neighbor’s unit. The association’s deductible may be charged back to you, which is what loss assessment coverage is for.

This article provides general educational information, not legal advice or a coverage determination. Policy wording on freezing, leakage, vacancy and mold differs between insurers, and how a claim is handled depends on the facts of the loss.

Coverage We Write

Call or text 847.242.1040 or request a quote online.