Short answer: a package stolen from your porch, lobby or mailroom after delivery is usually covered under the personal property part of a homeowners, condo or renters policy, because theft is a covered peril. The catch is the deductible. Most stolen packages are worth less than a $500 or $1,000 deductible, so the seller, the shipping company and your credit card are usually the better places to start.
Package theft peaks between Black Friday and the end of December, when deliveries pile up on porches and in building lobbies across Chicago and the suburbs. Insurance is the last line of defense here, not the first, and it helps to know the order to work through when a box goes missing.
Who to Ask First
| Step | Who | Why |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | The seller or retailer | Many retailers replace or refund packages reported missing, especially when the delivery photo shows an exposed spot |
| 2 | The shipping company | If the package was insured or marked delivered to the wrong address, the shipper may pay a claim |
| 3 | Your credit card | Some cards include purchase protection that covers theft for a limited time after purchase; check your card’s terms |
| 4 | The police | A report documents the theft and is often required by the card issuer or insurer |
| 5 | Your home, condo or renters policy | Worth it when the loss is well above your deductible, such as several gifts or one expensive item |
How the Deductible Math Works
Say a $350 pair of headphones disappears from your porch and your deductible is $1,000. The policy pays nothing, because the loss is under the deductible. If a box with $1,800 of electronics and gifts is stolen, the policy pays about $800. Whether that is worth a claim depends on your claim history and how your insurer prices claims. Our guide on when to file a homeowners claim and when to pay it yourself walks through the trade-off.
Theft claims also come with a documentation burden. Keep the order confirmation, the delivery notice and photo, any doorbell camera footage, and the police report number. Without proof of what was in the box and that it was delivered, a claim is hard to support.
Jewelry and Other Valuable Gifts
Standard homeowners and renters policies set special limits on certain kinds of property. A common one is $1,500 for theft of jewelry, watches and furs, no matter what the item cost. An engagement ring or a watch bought as a holiday gift and stolen from a porch, or later from the house, can be paid only up to that limit.
Scheduling the item, meaning listing it separately on the policy at an appraised value, removes the special limit and usually removes the deductible for that item too. It also covers loss, such as a ring that slips off in the snow, which a standard policy does not. Our page on valuable items insurance explains how scheduling works. The same idea applies to cameras, musical instruments and collectibles.
Gifts Stolen From Your Car
A shopping bag stolen from a parked car is personal property, so it is a claim on your homeowners, condo or renters policy, not your auto policy. The broken window is the opposite: it is damage to the car and falls under comprehensive coverage on the auto policy. Two claims, two deductibles, which is why a single break-in with a few gifts taken often makes sense to handle out of pocket. Keep gifts in the trunk and out of sight, and do not leave bags in the car overnight.
Renters and Condo Owners
Apartment and condo buildings concentrate package theft in lobbies and mailrooms. A building’s own insurance covers the building, not the residents’ deliveries, so a renter without a renters policy has no coverage for stolen belongings at all. Renters insurance usually runs about $10 to $25 a month and covers belongings, liability and loss of use. Condo owners have the same personal property coverage on an HO-6 policy.
Keeping Packages From Disappearing
- Have packages delivered to a pickup locker, a store, or your workplace if your employer allows it.
- Require a signature for anything expensive.
- Use the carrier’s delivery instructions to ask for a back door, side porch or garage delivery instead of the front step.
- Track deliveries and bring them in quickly, or ask a neighbor to.
- Install a lockbox or a parcel box for regular deliveries.
- A visible doorbell camera discourages some thieves and documents the theft if it happens.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does homeowners insurance cover stolen packages?
Usually yes, under personal property coverage, once the package has been delivered to you. The deductible applies, so many single packages are worth less than what you would pay before coverage starts.
Does renters insurance cover packages stolen from my building’s lobby?
Generally yes, subject to your deductible. The building’s insurance covers the building, not residents’ belongings, so renters insurance is what covers your stolen deliveries.
Who should I contact first when a package is stolen?
Start with the seller, which may replace or refund it, then the shipping company and your credit card’s purchase protection. File a police report, and turn to your insurance policy when the loss is well above your deductible.
Is a stolen engagement ring fully covered by homeowners insurance?
Not always. Many policies limit theft of jewelry to a set amount, often $1,500. Scheduling the ring at its appraised value removes that limit and usually covers loss as well as theft.
This article provides general educational information, not legal advice or a coverage determination. Special limits, deductibles and theft coverage differ between policies, and how a claim is handled depends on the facts and the policy language.
Coverage We Write
Call or text 847.242.1040 or request a quote online.
